General Resources on Assessment
If you think that there are things you do that simply can't be measured, someone else may have done the work for you by preparing a rubric to measure something that they do in their class. Rubrics provide a standardized way to rate critical components of classes and Winona State University has compiled an impressive list of rubrics for many topics.
Sample Home-Grown Instruments
Assessing General Education
Assessing the First Year Experience
The National Resource Center for the First Year Experience has also compiled a wealth of resources for assessing various components of a first year program.